I seriously don’t like His style of play, to me He is a Flop I don’t know why My club always wants to go for fairly used players”, Paul scholes reveals the only player Man United must sign instead of Manuel Ugarte
Former Manchester United star Paul Scholes has openly criticized the club’s transfer strategy, expressing his dissatisfaction with their tendency to sign older, experienced players rather than investing in younger talent. Scholes singled out the potential signing of Manuel Ugarte, saying he isn’t convinced by the player’s style or suitability for the team.
The thought of Manchester United signing Ilkay Gundogan, a player who has repeatedly troubled them in past encounters, particularly during his time with Manchester City, is unsettling for many fans. Gundogan, who left Barcelona after a disappointing season, is now returning to England, reportedly heading back to Manchester City. His return stirs up bad memories for United supporters, especially given his pivotal role in City’s victories over United, including the 2023 FA Cup final.
Paul Scholes, while reflecting on United’s transfer needs, suggested that a player with Gundogan’s qualities could be exactly what the team requires. He argued that United should consider signing a controlling midfielder who can manage the tempo of the game, someone like Gundogan or Real Sociedad’s Martin Zubimendi, who recently turned down a move to Liverpool.
Scholes voiced his concerns during an interview on “The Overlap,” expressing doubts about United’s pursuit of Manuel Ugarte, a young Uruguayan midfielder who is reportedly close to joining the club from Paris Saint-Germain for £51 million. Scholes admitted that he hasn’t seen much of Ugarte but questioned whether his aggressive, high-pressing style fits with what Manchester United currently needs. He compared Ugarte to former loanee Sofyan Amrabat, suggesting that United needs a more technically gifted player who can control games, rather than a tough-tackling midfielder.
Scholes emphasized that Manchester United requires a player with a tactical mind, someone who can slow down the pace of the game and bring more control to their play. He expressed skepticism about Ugarte’s technical ability and suitability for this role, pointing out that the club needs someone who can provide stability rather than simply win tackles and press aggressively.
While Ugarte is known for his relentless energy and aggressive playing style, Scholes believes that Manchester United would benefit more from a midfielder with composure and intelligence on the ball, someone who can dictate the tempo of matches rather than contributing to the current fast-paced, end-to-end style that often leads to unpredictable results. However, if manager Erik ten Hag intends to transform United into a high-pressing team similar to Liverpool under Jurgen Klopp, Ugarte could still prove to be a valuable addition, even if Scholes remains unconvinced.Paul Scholes has openly criticized Manchester United’s recent transfer strategy, particularly their focus on signing older, experienced players rather than younger talents. He expressed specific concerns about the potential signing of Manuel Ugarte, a young Uruguayan midfielder reportedly close to joining United from Paris Saint-Germain for £51 million. Scholes questioned whether Ugarte’s aggressive, high-pressing style fits Manchester United’s current needs, noting that he hasn’t seen much of the player but is unsure if Ugarte’s attributes align with what the team requires.
Scholes believes that United needs a technically gifted midfielder who can control the tempo of games, someone with the qualities of Ilkay Gundogan or Real Sociedad’s Martin Zubimendi. He suggested that a player like Gundogan, despite his past success against United while at Manchester City, would be an ideal fit for the team. Gundogan’s return to Manchester City, after a brief stint at Barcelona, has unsettled United fans, especially given his role in City’s dominance over United, including the 2023 FA Cup final.
During an interview on “The Overlap,” Scholes highlighted the need for a tactically intelligent midfielder who can bring stability and composure to United’s play, rather than just energy and aggression. He compared Ugarte to former loanee Sofyan Amrabat, arguing that United needs someone who can slow down the game and dictate play. Scholes remains skeptical about Ugarte’s ability to fulfill this role, emphasizing the importance of a midfielder who can control matches rather than contribute to the team’s current fast-paced, unpredictable style.
Scholes’ comments reflect a broader concern about United’s transfer approach and the need for balance between youth and experience, technical skill, and tactical acumen. While Ugarte’s energy and pressing ability could suit a high-intensity system, Scholes believes that a player with more composure and intelligence on the ball is crucial for United’s long-term success.
