I don’t think Ruben Amorim will succeed at Man United and here is why…”: Pep Guardiola says Ruben Amorim has made a fatal error in just few hours after his takeover, advised him to revert his decision with immediate effect. DO YOU THINK PEP IS RIGHT?
Ruben Amorim has wasted no time in making significant decisions as Manchester United’s new head coach, starting with the dismissal of Ruud van Nistelrooy from the club’s coaching staff.
Van Nistelrooy, who stepped in as interim manager after Erik ten Hag’s sacking, led United to an unbeaten four-match run with three wins and a draw. His short spell was seen as a stabilizing period for the team, and there’s recognition that he helped stop the downward spiral. However, on Amorim’s first day in the role, he informed Van Nistelrooy face-to-face that his services would no longer be required, as the Portuguese manager brought his own staff from Sporting CP.
Van Nistelrooy, who turned down other managerial opportunities to become Ten Hag’s assistant last summer, had expressed a willingness to work under Amorim. The decision to part ways will undoubtedly be a disappointment for the Dutchman, who had hoped to remain at Old Trafford.
Rio Ferdinand and Owen Hargreaves Question Amorim’s Call
Former United defender Rio Ferdinand, who played alongside Van Nistelrooy, praised his former teammate’s performance as caretaker manager. Speaking on his *Rio Ferdinand Presents* podcast, Ferdinand said:
“His audition couldn’t have gone any better. There was a steely determination from him to either stay at the club or attract attention as a manager elsewhere. He looked the part and delivered results.
The players needed that stability. There was a lot of turbulence, fractured relationships with the previous manager, and fans who had made their minds up about a change. Van Nistelrooy didn’t just bring a new-manager bounce—it felt deeper. The players respected him and wanted to perform for him.”
Owen Hargreaves also echoed Ferdinand’s sentiments, highlighting the rapport Van Nistelrooy had built with the squad and the tactical insights he provided.
What’s Next for Amorim?
Amorim now shifts his focus to preparing for his first match in charge, a Premier League clash against Ipswich Town on November 24. While his decision to let go of Van Nistelrooy has drawn criticism, Amorim’s tenure will ultimately be judged on his ability to revitalize United and improve their position in the league.
Ruben Amorim’s bold decision to dismiss Ruud van Nistelrooy from Manchester United’s coaching staff signals a clear intent to assert his authority and implement his own vision from day one. While Van Nistelrooy’s brief but impactful stint as interim manager earned him widespread praise for stabilizing the team, Amorim’s preference for a familiar coaching setup underscores his confidence in the methods that brought him success at Sporting CP.
### Criticism of Amorim’s Decision
Van Nistelrooy’s departure has sparked debate among fans and pundits alike. His ability to rally the squad during a turbulent period and deliver a strong unbeaten record showcased his managerial potential. Rio Ferdinand and Owen Hargreaves’ comments highlight the respect Van Nistelrooy garnered, not just for his results but for his leadership and tactical acumen. His efforts to repair fractured relationships and instill stability were seen as crucial to United’s short-term recovery.
The criticism Amorim faces centers on whether dismissing Van Nistelrooy risks undoing the progress made during his interim tenure. Many fans hoped the Dutchman would remain involved, at least to ease the transition.
### Amorim’s Immediate Challenges
Amorim’s task now is to justify this controversial decision by achieving results quickly. With United currently underperforming in the league, the Portuguese manager will need to hit the ground running, starting with the match against Ipswich Town. Integrating his new staff and philosophy while maintaining the team’s morale will be critical.
### What Lies Ahead for Van Nistelrooy?
For Van Nistelrooy, this setback may open doors elsewhere. His strong showing as caretaker manager and growing reputation suggest he won’t be short of opportunities, either in England or abroad. Clubs seeking a proven leader with a strong understanding of top-level football might see him as an attractive candidate.
Ultimately, Amorim’s ability to win over skeptics will hinge on delivering sustained success. If his tenure starts poorly, the decision to part ways with Van Nistelrooy could loom large as a point of contention.
