Manchester United could be facing another major dressing-room problem following the dismissal of Michael Carrick, with Matheus Cunha reportedly unhappy about the club’s decision to part ways with the former manager.
The Brazilian forward is allegedly considering his future at Old Trafford and could push for a January departure after losing the manager he believed was capable of leading Manchester United into a new era.
The development would represent another significant setback for the club, which has already endured a difficult campaign and recently appointed Mauricio Pochettino to replace Carrick.
According to the circulating statement, Cunha believes Carrick was not the problem behind United’s disappointing performances. Instead, he allegedly feels certain individuals within the dressing room failed to give the former manager the support he needed.
The alleged statement reads:
“I’m not happy and I have been clear about Carrick and the club sacking him. He was the right man for the job — it was just that these two players I call teammates were not supporting him.
“I don’t want to be here anymore. Carrick is gone and I want to leave with immediate effect.
“I saw a future with Carrick that the club failed to see. It feels like I joined a club with wrong and fake ambition.
“Come January I want to leave. I can’t be here anymore.”
If genuine, those comments would raise serious questions about the atmosphere inside the Manchester United dressing room and the club’s ability to convince its players to buy into another rebuilding project.
CUNHA WAS ONE OF CARRICK’S BIGGEST SUPPORTERS
What makes this allegation particularly interesting is that Cunha previously spoke very positively about Carrick.
Following United’s dramatic 3-2 Champions League victory over Roma on November 3, the Brazilian praised the manager’s influence and explained why he believed the club needed to build its future around the current generation.
Cunha was particularly impressed by Carrick’s connection to Manchester United’s history and the way he communicated the expectations associated with playing for the club.
He described having a manager like Carrick, who reminded players of United’s great moments under Sir Alex Ferguson, as something special.
Cunha also emphasised that the current squad had a responsibility to create its own history rather than simply celebrate what previous generations achieved.
His comments were significant because they demonstrated how much he valued Carrick’s influence.
Consequently, the manager’s dismissal could understandably become a major talking point among supporters wondering how different players have reacted to the decision. (Sport Witness)
THE ROMA PERFORMANCE THAT SHOWED CUNHA’S IMPORTANCE
Cunha also delivered one of his most memorable performances under Carrick during that Champions League encounter.
Manchester United found themselves trailing Roma 2-0 after goals from Matias Soulé and Donyell Malen.
The situation looked disastrous for the home side, particularly considering their difficult run of results.
However, United produced an impressive second-half comeback.
Bruno Fernandes converted a penalty before Cunha scored twice in quick succession, completing a remarkable turnaround and securing a 3-2 victory.
His contribution demonstrated the attacking quality he could bring to the team when given freedom to operate across the frontline.
Unfortunately, the Brazilian was also sent off late in the match after receiving two yellow cards.
Nevertheless, his performance provided another example of why Carrick valued his versatility and attacking ability. (Talksport)
CARRICK’S DISMISSAL HAS CREATED ANOTHER UNCERTAIN PERIOD
Manchester United officially dismissed Carrick on November 12 after a disappointing beginning to the 2026/27 campaign.
The former midfielder had previously guided the club to third place in the Premier League during the second half of the previous season, winning 12 of his remaining 17 league matches.
That achievement earned him a permanent contract, but results deteriorated dramatically during the new campaign.
United managed just three victories in their first 15 matches across all competitions, while their league position dropped into the relegation zone.
Their 4-4 draw against Aston Villa on November 8 proved another frustrating result, and the club’s hierarchy eventually decided that a managerial change was necessary.
Carrick’s departure was confirmed four days later. (Sky News)
For supporters, the decision raised an uncomfortable question: was changing the manager enough to solve the club’s deeper problems?
POCHETTINO NOW FACES A DIFFICULT DRESSING-ROOM CHALLENGE
Mauricio Pochettino has officially taken over from Carrick, signing a contract that runs until the summer of 2029.
The Argentine arrives with considerable experience from his previous spells at Tottenham, Chelsea and Paris Saint-Germain.
United will expect him to improve performances, restore confidence and establish a stronger identity within the squad.
However, his biggest challenge might not simply be tactical.
He must convince the players that the club has a clear direction and that everyone has an important role to play in the rebuilding process.
If certain players are genuinely unhappy with the managerial change, Pochettino will need to address those concerns quickly.
He cannot afford to begin his Manchester United career with uncertainty surrounding the commitment of important members of his squad.
The January transfer window could therefore become particularly important as he assesses the players he wants to keep and those who might not fit his plans. (Sky Sports)
JANUARY COULD BECOME A MAJOR TEST FOR UNITED
If Cunha genuinely wants to leave, Manchester United could face a difficult decision.
The Brazilian was brought to Old Trafford to provide attacking quality, creativity and goals.
His ability to operate across different attacking positions makes him a valuable option, particularly for a manager who wants flexibility in the final third.
Allowing him to leave would mean finding another player capable of providing similar qualities.
However, keeping an unhappy player could also create complications if the reported frustration reflects wider dissatisfaction within the squad.
Pochettino will need to establish his authority while ensuring that important decisions are made in the best interests of the football club.
United cannot afford another transfer window dominated by uncertainty and disagreements.
LIVERPOOL COULD BE WAITING FOR AN OPPORTUNITY
There is another important date approaching for Manchester United.
Pochettino’s first match in charge is scheduled to be against Liverpool at Anfield on November 22.
It will be an enormous examination of the new manager’s ability to organise his players and immediately improve the team’s performances.
Liverpool will undoubtedly want to take advantage of United’s difficult circumstances.
For Cunha, the coming weeks could be important in determining whether he remains part of Pochettino’s plans.
A strong relationship with the new manager could change the situation, but a breakdown in trust would make January an interesting period.
WILL CUNHA REALLY LEAVE MANCHESTER UNITED?
The Brazilian’s alleged reaction to Carrick’s dismissal has created another talking point around Old Trafford.
His previous public praise of Carrick makes the circulating claims particularly interesting, but there is currently no verified confirmation that Cunha has requested a transfer or intends to leave in January.
There is also no independently confirmed evidence that two unnamed teammates failed to support Carrick.
For now, Pochettino’s priority will be getting the squad together, understanding the problems and preparing for the demanding fixtures ahead.
But if the reported frustration is genuine, United could have another major situation to resolve before the January window opens.