After talking with him, I found put that he was never a good coach, so I couldn’t afford to waste any more time under his terrible management. I have to leave the club, and now I am one of the best Midfielder in Premier League”-Former Man United player reveals he had to leave the club after just one conversation with Erik ten Hag when he took over.

Former Manchester United player James Garner has shared insights into his decision to leave the club, revealing that it took just one conversation with manager Erik ten Hag to make up his mind.

Ten Hag took charge of United in May 2022, succeeding interim manager Ralf Rangnick. Since his arrival, several high-profile players have exited the club, including Cristiano Ronaldo after his controversial interview with Piers Morgan.

Garner, who left for Everton in September 2022 in a deal worth around £15 million, spoke to *BBC Sport* in 2023 about his departure. He explained that a direct conversation with Ten Hag was pivotal in his decision to seek opportunities elsewhere.

“Ten Hag is very approachable but also very strict. He doesn’t tolerate anyone breaking the rules. He’s straightforward and holds people accountable if they do something wrong,” Garner said.

“My conversation with him was straightforward. I asked him directly if I would be part of the squad or if he saw a role for me. I didn’t get the response I was hoping for, so I decided to leave.”

Garner, who had just enjoyed a standout season, wanted to continue playing regularly rather than risk being on the bench. “I had a great season before that, probably the best I could have had, and I didn’t want to stagnate by sitting on the bench every week. Nothing is guaranteed in football, but when the club starts signing three or four midfielders, you start to understand where you stand.”

During his time at United, Garner made only seven appearances and spent significant time on loan at Watford and Nottingham Forest, where he found more playing time. Since joining Everton, the 23-year-old has become a regular, with 63 appearances, two goals, and three assists from his defensive midfield position.James Garner’s decision to leave Manchester United in September 2022 for Everton stemmed from a straightforward conversation with manager Erik ten Hag. Garner revealed in a 2023 interview with *BBC Sport* that while Ten Hag was approachable, he was also strict about discipline and accountability. When Garner inquired about his future at United and whether he would be part of Ten Hag’s squad, the response was not what he had hoped for.

After enjoying a strong season on loan, Garner sought regular playing time but realized his chances at United were limited, especially with the club bringing in several new midfielders. Having made only seven appearances for United and spending time on loan at Watford and Nottingham Forest, Garner decided to move on. Since joining Everton, he has become a key player, making 63 appearances and contributing from his defensive midfield role.