In a gritty start to the 2025-26 Premier League campaign, Arsenal edged out Manchester United 1-0 at Old Trafford on August 17, 2025, thanks to an early header from summer signing Riccardo Calafiori. The match, which pitted Mikel Arteta’s title hopefuls against Ruben Amorim’s revamped Red Devils, was a tense affair dominated by defensive resilience rather than attacking flair, with Arsenal holding firm despite United’s persistent pressure.
The Gunners struck first in the 13th minute when Declan Rice whipped in an inswinging corner from the left. Manchester United goalkeeper Altay Bayindir, under pressure from William Saliba, failed to punch the ball clear, allowing Calafiori to nod home from close range under the crossbar. The goal survived protests from United players, who claimed a foul on their keeper, but VAR upheld the decision. Arsenal nearly doubled their lead shortly after, but Bukayo Saka’s effort was blocked.
Manchester United responded with vigor, enjoying spells of dominance. Patrick Dorgu rattled the post with a low drive from outside the box, and Matheus Cunha forced a sharp save from David Raya after breaking through the Arsenal backline. In the second half, the hosts ramped up their attacks, with Bryan Mbeumo’s header palmed away by Raya and substitute Benjamin Sesko heading wide. Late drama ensued as Saliba produced a heroic last-ditch tackle to deny Cunha from two yards out, and Harry Maguire’s stoppage-time header was comfortably saved by Raya.
Statistically, United edged possession at around 55% and registered more shots, but Arsenal’s set-piece prowess—having scored 14 goals from corners last season—proved decisive once again. Arteta’s side showed maturity in absorbing pressure, securing a clean sheet on the road against a lively opponent eager to impress under new management.
Players Who Shone Brightly
Amid a match low on spectacle, several players stood out for their composure and impact. Riccardo Calafiori was the hero for Arsenal, not only scoring the winner with a well-timed header but also delivering a assured performance at left-back on his competitive debut. The Italian’s defensive work rate and aerial presence earned him ratings as high as 7.9/10, with pundits hailing his seamless integration into the backline.
David Raya earned Player of the Match honors with a commanding display in goal, making crucial saves including a low stop from Cunha in the first half and a vital push away from Mbeumo’s header. His distribution and handling under siege were exemplary, garnering 9/10 ratings and underscoring why he’s Arteta’s undisputed No. 1.
William Saliba anchored the defense superbly, culminating in that game-saving tackle on Cunha in the 89th minute. The Frenchman’s reading of the game and physicality were key to Arsenal’s shutout, with ratings around 7.3/10 reflecting his reliability.
Declan Rice also impressed in midfield, providing the assist for the goal with a pinpoint corner and breaking up United’s transitions effectively. His all-action display, rated 7-8/10, offered stability in a scrappy encounter.
For Manchester United, Matheus Cunha was a constant menace on his debut, linking play intelligently and creating multiple chances. The Brazilian’s energy and dribbling troubled Arsenal’s defenders, earning him praise as the standout debutant with ratings up to 7.5/10.
Bryan Mbeumo complemented Cunha well, delivering dangerous crosses and testing Raya with a powerful header. His lively performance on the right flank, rated around 6.8-7/10, hinted at a promising season ahead.
Players Who Fell Short of Expectations
Not everyone rose to the occasion in this opener. Viktor Gyokeres, Arsenal’s high-profile summer acquisition leading the line on his debut, had a forgettable afternoon. The Swedish striker struggled to hold up play, registered no shots on target, and was isolated for long periods, leading to ratings as low as 5/10. His lack of involvement raised early questions about his adaptation to the Premier League’s intensity.
Gabriel Martinelli also underperformed on the left wing, failing to provide his usual spark. The Brazilian was subdued by United’s defense, with wayward crosses and minimal threat, resulting in ratings dipping to 5-6/10 and descriptions of a “nightmare” outing.
Ben White, typically reliable at right-back, had a mixed game marked by an early booking and a moment where he was accused of simulation by Cunha. While solid defensively, his attacking contributions were limited, earning 6-7.4/10 but falling short of his high standards.
