He’s Definitely Leaving This Summer, The Announcement Might Come On Monday. And His Replacement Is This Brilliant Manager” – Harry Redknapp Confirms That Man United Will Hire A ‘Brilliant’ Manager After Erik Ten Hag Is Dismissed This Summer.
Harry Redknapp has disclosed who he believes Manchester United truly desire as their next manager.
The Red Devils are still deliberating on whether to retain Erik ten Hag.
While it appeared likely that the Dutchman would be dismissed, United’s FA Cup victory at Wembley has slightly improved his chances of staying.
**Pochettino or Southgate – Who is Better for Manchester United?**
Manchester United must make the right choice if they decide to part ways with Ten Hag. Both Mauricio Pochettino and Gareth Southgate have been linked to the managerial position at Old Trafford, and they may be the top contenders on INEOS’ shortlist.
Between the two, the decision seems clear. Pochettino has achieved significantly more success at the club level, notably helping his team finish sixth in the 2023/24 season, above Manchester United, despite a poor start to the campaign.
In contrast, Southgate, praised by Roy Keane as “brilliant,” recently led England in another disappointing performance, this time against Iceland, ranked 72nd by FIFA.
Pochettino appears to be a better fit for Manchester United, though Redknapp and others believe Southgate might ultimately be chosen.
When comparing Mauricio Pochettino and Gareth Southgate as potential managers for Manchester United, several factors need to be considered:
### Mauricio Pochettino:
1. **Club-Level Experience and Success**:
– Pochettino has a strong track record at the club level, having managed teams like Espanyol, Southampton, Tottenham Hotspur, and Paris Saint-Germain (PSG).
– His notable achievements include leading Tottenham to the Champions League final in 2019 and consistently securing top-four finishes in the Premier League.
– His tactical acumen and ability to develop young players have been widely praised.
2. **Recent Performance**:
– Pochettino’s recent season, where he finished above Manchester United with his team despite a poor start, demonstrates his resilience and strategic adjustments.
### Gareth Southgate:
1. **International Experience**:
– Southgate has been managing the England national team since 2016, leading them to the 2018 World Cup semi-finals and the Euro 2020 final.
– His tenure has been marked by a strong emphasis on team unity, youth development, and a clear playing style.
2. **Challenges at Club Level**:
– Unlike Pochettino, Southgate lacks significant experience managing at the club level, which could be a critical drawback for a club as demanding as Manchester United.
– Recent criticisms, including a disappointing performance against Iceland, highlight potential concerns about his ability to adapt to the week-in, week-out pressures of club football.
### Decision Factors for Manchester United:
1. **Track Record**:
– Pochettino’s extensive experience and success in club football make him a more proven choice for a club aiming to return to the top of both domestic and European competitions.
2. **Suitability and Style**:
– Pochettino’s tactical flexibility and experience in high-pressure club environments align well with the demands of managing Manchester United.
– Southgate’s strengths in player management and fostering a positive team environment are commendable, but the transition from international to club football is a significant leap.
### Conclusion:
While both managers have their merits, Mauricio Pochettino appears to be the more suitable candidate for Manchester United based on his extensive club-level experience, proven track record, and tactical prowess. Harry Redknapp’s suggestion that Southgate might be considered could stem from Southgate’s leadership qualities and recent experiences with England, but Pochettino’s credentials at the club level provide a stronger foundation for success at Old Trafford.
