It’s clear as day that he’s not happy at Old Trafford despite being there for a long time. It’s best you just leave him and build your squad without putting him into mind. He should leave by January” – This is according to Paul Scholes as a Manchester United player who reportedly had disagreements with Erik ten Hag appears to be creating challenges for new manager Ruben Amorim. The individual, known for inconsistent performances despite having huge talent, seems to be struggling to adapt to Amorim’s tactical demands due to his lack of motivation to fight for the club, potentially impacting the team’s cohesion. Amorim is advised by the Scholes to build the team without including the said player in his plans

Ruben Amorim has quickly encountered a challenge familiar to his predecessor Erik ten Hag during his early days as Manchester United manager. Former midfielder Owen Hargreaves highlighted Amorim’s frustration during the 1-1 draw against Ipswich Town at Portman Road, noting similarities to issues Ten Hag faced with Marcus Rashford.

Amorim’s debut saw United take an early lead through Marcus Rashford’s quick strike from an Amad Diallo assist, but the Red Devils failed to maintain control. Ipswich responded strongly, and it was only Andre Onana’s heroics that prevented further goals. However, Amorim’s visible frustration on the sidelines suggested deeper concerns, particularly with Rashford’s off-ball performance—a recurring problem during Ten Hag’s tenure.

Hargreaves, speaking to Premier League Productions, commented, “Amorim seemed very frustrated. He was animated on the touchline, especially about Rashford’s positioning when the team didn’t have the ball. It appeared Rashford wasn’t fully attuned to the tactical demands Amorim was emphasizing.”

Rashford, who excelled under Ten Hag with 30 goals during the Dutchman’s first season, also experienced disciplinary issues. From on-field tactical lapses to off-field controversies—like partying before matches—Rashford occasionally strained his relationship with the former boss. Ten Hag openly criticized Rashford’s defensive contributions and took firm actions to instill discipline, setting a precedent Amorim may also need to follow.

The Portuguese coach employed his favored 3-4-3 system against Ipswich, but Hargreaves observed that several players seemed out of position or uncomfortable in their roles. “Four or five players looked like they were playing outside their natural roles. It didn’t seem to suit them,” he remarked, adding that Amorim’s tactical adjustments, particularly with Joshua Zirkzee and Rasmus Hojlund, showed room for improvement.

United’s struggles in adapting to Amorim’s system were evident, as they lacked cohesion and balance. With just two Premier League goals this season, Rashford will need to adapt to Amorim’s tactical demands to regain form and contribute more effectively.

United next face Bodo/Glimt in the Europa League before hosting Everton at Old Trafford. Amorim has work to do to align his tactical philosophy with his players’ strengths and instill the discipline necessary to navigate these challenges effectively.

Ruben Amorim’s tenure as Manchester United manager has started with challenges reminiscent of Erik ten Hag’s early days, particularly in managing Marcus Rashford’s tactical discipline. The 1-1 draw against Ipswich Town at Portman Road highlighted both promise and frustration for Amorim, as United struggled to control the game after Rashford’s early goal from an Amad Diallo assist.

Former United midfielder Owen Hargreaves pointed out Amorim’s visible irritation on the sidelines, specifically with Rashford’s off-ball positioning. Rashford’s inconsistency in meeting tactical expectations was a familiar issue under Ten Hag, who had openly criticized his defensive contributions and occasionally benched him to enforce discipline.

Amorim opted for his trademark 3-4-3 formation against Ipswich, but several players appeared uncomfortable or misaligned with the system. Hargreaves noted, “It looked like four or five players were playing out of position, and it didn’t seem to suit their natural strengths.” This includes Joshua Zirkzee and Rasmus Hojlund, who struggled to adapt to Amorim’s tactics.

Andre Onana was pivotal in ensuring United avoided defeat, making crucial saves that masked the team’s lack of cohesion and balance. However, the broader issues—limited creativity, poor off-ball movement, and tactical discomfort—underscore the uphill battle Amorim faces to implement his philosophy.

Rashford’s form is particularly concerning. After scoring 30 goals in Ten Hag’s debut season, the forward’s impact has waned, with just two Premier League goals this season. For Amorim’s system to succeed, Rashford must adapt to the Portuguese manager’s tactical demands and rediscover his consistency.

United’s next fixtures, a Europa League clash against Bodo/Glimt and a home Premier League match against Everton, provide Amorim with opportunities to refine his approach. The manager will need to address his team’s positional discomfort and defensive lapses while instilling the discipline required to succeed at the highest level.